The Medium is the Mess

Stan has written a thoughtful piece called What’s Golden. Therein he examines the tried and trusted golden ratio and finds it very difficult to apply to the unpredictable dimensions of the web browser:

I’m not saying that using these principles is a dead end, what I am saying is their usefulness is questionable for web design. … I’m not in favor of restricting content to a scrolling box, or jumping through hoops to regulate the size of content, pages, and browser windows. These methods push the problems on the viewers.

Jackson takes on the truism that the ideal line length for print also applies to the web. In The Line Length Misconception he rebuffs this cut’n’dried solution, backing up his claims with research (and finishing up with a call for more research):

So should you really be limiting your line length to 75 characters? This research suggests you shouldn’t. Users will be perfectly fine reading longer columns of text. … There may be a good opportunity for some new and more thorough research in this area that could offer some valuable new insight.

Malarkey then clobbers us with his Lead Pipe, rightly pointing out that there is no one single correct value for line-height. He lists a range of factors that should affect the decision:

…dark text against a light background … your line lengths … the x-height of your chosen typeface?

I, for one, welcome our rulebook-questioning overlords. Yes, we can learn from the many years of work that went into divining rules of thumb for other mediums but we should also remember that the web is not just a new and different medium; it’s an ever-changing, ever-evolving medium. That can be frustrating but I also find it incredibly exciting and liberating.

John wrote A Dao Of Web Design almost a decade ago. It rings truer with each day:

Now is the time for the medium of the web to outgrow its origins in the printed page. Not to abandon so much wisdom and experience, but to also chart its own course, where appropriate.

The web’s greatest strength, I believe, is often seen as a limitation, as a defect. It is the nature of the web to be flexible, and it should be our role as designers and developers to embrace this flexibility, and produce pages which, by being flexible, are accessible to all.

The journey begins by letting go of control, and becoming flexible.

Have you published a response to this? :

Previously on this day

12 years ago I wrote Why You Should Have a Web Site

Liveblogging a presentation by Steven Pemberton at XTech 2008 in Dublin.

12 years ago I wrote Data Portability For Whom?

Liveblogging a talk by Gavin Bell at XTech 2008 in Dublin.

12 years ago I wrote Ni Hao, Monde: Connecting Communities Across Cultural and Linguistic Boundaries

Liveblogging a presentation by Simon Batistoni at XTech 2008 in Dublin.

12 years ago I wrote AMEE — The World’s Energy Meter

Liveblogging a talk by Gavin Starks at XTech 2008 in Dublin.

14 years ago I wrote The waste (memory wastes)

Grant McLennan RIP

16 years ago I wrote Brighton rock

The Brighton Festival is in full swing. Everywhere you look, there’s theatre, music, dance and art.

17 years ago I wrote Malkovich, Malkovich

Malkovich this Malkovich.